Bull Mastiff Vs. German Shepherd

I'm debating adding another dog to my family. In my house its just my wife and I. We are thinking of a German Shepherd or a Bullmastiff. Wife wants a rotty but I don't particularly like them. We have a 3 month old female black lab as well.. Which would you guys recommend for house defense ? I don't want an overly aggressive dog that can't get along with others, or children god forbid. I would like to have a dog that intimidates anyone who is trying to break in. I'm torn between a bullmastiff and a German Sheperd.
Size,sheddding,training, etc are of no concern to me. If you buy a dog, you should expect all 3.
Posted: May 10, 2013

Best Answer

Wait on the puppy until the Labrador is grown up enough to be under control - two puppies are usually a recipe for disaster.
After that, get the breed that better fits you needs and goals. Even the Labrador will provide a STRONG deterrent to anyone breaking in - large, black in color, barking like a fiend. Other than that, the Bullmastiff probably *looks* more intimidating but the German Shepherd is doubtlessly easier to train for any sort of formal guardian or protection work.

Related Questions

2+
answers
Present My German Shepherd To A Pit Bull Puppy
I have a friend who recently got a pit bull puppy and she's six months old i have a female german shepherd puppy who is spayed and is also six months old how wo...
May 10, 2013
9+
answers
Out Of These Dogs, Which One Would You Buy?
and why would you buy it? German Shepherd Doberman Rottweiler Belgian Malinois Dutch Shepherd Xaine- I already own a German shepherd :) I am planning on...
May 29, 2013
4+
answers
What Does It Mean To Have A Bull Mastiff In My Dream?
It was a little weird, because I am not THAT much into bull mastiffs. I only have a neapolitan mastiff and a yellow lab mix. The dog in my dream looked exactly ...
May 10, 2013
6+
answers
What Have They Done To The German Shepherd
I just watched a short video clip on the 'show' German Shepherd...those dogs have horribly curved backs it almost looks painful is this really breed standard? ...
May 10, 2013
5+
answers
I Can't Put Together My Two Dogs! Me
I have two dogs, a female labrador retriever, 9 months old (I have it since it was 1 month old) and a male german shepherd, 2 months old that we bought a month ...
May 20, 2013
3+
answers
I'm Confused Were To Put My Gsd?
you might have seen my last Question and I said that my mom wants to put the German Shepherd Dog in the garage and that I have a small yard but I got a better I...
June 14, 2013
7+
answers
Why Don't Dog Fighters Use These Breeds?
Pit Bulls do make great dogs for fighting, but there are other breeds that are bigger and more powerful... why don't they fight anything else besides Pit Bulls?...
May 29, 2013
6+
answers
Help With Feeding Dogs?
So, I have four dogs. I free feed my dogs (leave two bowls of food out so they can eat whenever they get hungry). Two of my dogs are very good with food and ...
May 10, 2013
3+
answers
My Bull Mastiff Puppy Is In Heat, But...?
Okay, so..my bull mastiff is only 5 months old..I got told they usually go into heat at like..6 to 8 months..so is this okay at 5 months? (She was bleeding "dow...
May 10, 2013
8+
answers
Can't Afford To Buy A German Shepherd Dog.?
Can't afford to buy a German shepherd dog. And I wanted my black Labrador retriever to have puppies. I so love her, she's 5 years old now. I want Labrador mixed...
May 19, 2013
8+
answers
O German Shepherds Are Aggressive?
i was at the pet store today, we put the german shepherd and a golden retriever in the same room to hang with us. at first the german shepherd was shy, the g...
May 20, 2013
7+
answers
What Are Some Really Good Pit Bull Dog Facts?
I have a German Shepherd and I love him to death. He has always loved to play but sometimes I just don't have time to play with him so I want a playmate for him...
May 10, 2013
3+
answers
Introducing 2 German Shepherds?
I have a 2 year old male German shepherd who is pretty aggressive around dogs he doesn't know. My dad wants to bring another male german shepherd to live in our...
May 10, 2013
4+
answers
For An Apartment: Is A German Shepherd An Appropriate Dog Choice?
I have a very large space for the dog to exercise in.. but it's not fenced in. Will this cause issues? I was thinking about getting a husky or malamute.. but...
May 10, 2013
6+
answers
What Type Of German Shepherd Should I Get
I know there are many types of shepherd dogs out there. I love dogs and am a very active person. As of know i have one Golden Retriever, she is almost 12 yea...
May 10, 2013

Page Loaded:0.03